Note that this visual is based on the previous version of the Hall of wWAR.

Hall of wWAR

The Hall of Fame Re-Populated by Weighted WAR

WAR vs. WAA (Position Players, 1871–2009)

Wins Above Replacement (WAR) is a great tool for finding the overall value a player provided… over a replacement player. But, when talking about the Hall of Fame (as I often like to do), should we really be comparing candidates to replacement players? It makes sense to do so when discussing active major league players and roster construction. However, when looking back on a player’s career and comparing him to the all time greats, perhaps we should hold him to a higher standard.

One of the complaints about using WAR as a Hall of Fame measuring stick is that it rewards “compilers”, or players who lasted a long time without necessarily providing a great deal of value. That’s because a player who hangs around for twenty years at a league average level is actually a very valuable commodity when building a team—but he is not a Hall of Famer. In the Hall of wWAR, I’ve tried to account for this by double-counting WAR above 3.0 (for Wins Above Excellence) and triple-counting WAR above 6.0 (for Wins Above MVP). But what would happen if we just threw everything away that lies between those “replacement” and “average” lines?

Enter Wins Above Average.

The graph below displays all 278 position players with 40+ WAR through 2009. Why only through 2009? I worked from Sean Smith’s WAR spreadsheets (for convenience—the WAR components are more flexible than in Baseball-Reference’s Play Index). I added each batting, fielding, baserunning, and positional component together since they are all normalized to league average (there is an additional replacement adjustment that I’m leaving out). Then, I ran those through a run-to-win converter (Tango’s RPW) based on the scoring environment of that season. Finally, I added them all up to get career Wins Above Average.

The graph displays each player’s Wins Above Average and their Replacement Wins (which is WAR accumulated between the replacement level and the average level—in other words, WAR − WAA). Beneath the graph is the same data in table form.

Key
Wins Above Replacement
Wins Above Average
Replacement Wins
Babe Ruth
172.0
140.5
31.5
Barry Bonds
171.8
131.3
40.5
Ty Cobb
159.4
114.8
44.6
Willie Mays
154.7
113.5
41.2
Hank Aaron
141.6
94.2
47.4
Honus Wagner
134.5
100.6
33.9
Tris Speaker
133.0
93.8
39.2
Rogers Hornsby
127.8
99.2
28.6
Stan Musial
127.8
84.7
43.1
Eddie Collins
126.7
88.2
38.5
Ted Williams
125.3
98.5
26.8
Mickey Mantle
120.2
90.0
30.2
Lou Gehrig
118.4
90.9
27.5
Rickey Henderson
113.1
74.6
38.5
Mel Ott
109.3
71.5
37.8
Mike Schmidt
108.3
76.6
31.7
Frank Robinson
107.4
66.6
40.8
Nap Lajoie
104.2
70.3
33.9
Joe Morgan
103.5
68.9
34.6
Cap Anson
99.5
63.4
36.1
Alex Rodriguez
99.0
68.8
30.2
Eddie Mathews
98.3
64.7
33.6
Jimmie Foxx
94.1
66.7
27.4
Al Kaline
91.0
56.6
34.4
George Davis
90.7
59.0
31.7
Cal Ripken
89.9
50.8
39.1
Wade Boggs
89.0
57.5
31.5
Carl Yastrzemski
88.7
46.3
42.4
Roger Connor
87.2
58.5
28.7
George Brett
85.0
49.5
35.5
Roberto Clemente
83.8
50.5
33.3
Dan Brouthers
83.7
61.5
22.2
Joe DiMaggio
83.6
63.8
19.8
Charlie Gehringer
80.9
51.0
29.9
Jeff Bagwell
79.9
52.4
27.5
Ken Griffey
79.3
45.0
34.3
Rod Carew
79.1
47.0
32.1
Chipper Jones
76.9
49.8
27.1
Robin Yount
76.9
40.2
36.7
Pujols Albert
76.6
58.2
18.4
Sam Crawford
76.6
38.9
37.7
Bill Dahlen
75.9
44.9
31.0
Frank Thomas
75.9
44.4
31.5
Arky Vaughan
75.6
50.2
25.4
Pete Rose
75.3
28.2
47.1
Frankie Frisch
74.8
45.5
29.3
Paul Molitor
74.8
39.5
35.3
Ed Delahanty
74.7
50.2
24.5
Reggie Jackson
74.6
36.9
37.7
Paul Waner
73.8
41.3
32.5
Fred Clarke
73.4
44.8
28.6
Johnny Bench
71.3
46.2
25.1
Johnny Mize
70.2
44.1
26.1
Lou Whitaker
69.7
39.7
30.0
Billy Hamilton
69.6
48.7
20.9
Harry Heilmann
69.4
40.3
29.1
Luke Appling
69.3
40.8
28.5
Brooks Robinson
69.1
38.8
30.3
Barry Larkin
68.9
42.4
26.5
Jeter Derek
68.8
38.9
29.9
Tony Gwynn
68.4
37.6
30.8
Jesse Burkett
68.0
40.0
28.0
Bobby Grich
67.6
42.7
24.9
Duke Snider
67.5
38.8
28.7
Larry Walker
67.3
43.0
24.3
Carlton Fisk
67.3
36.2
31.1
Edgar Martinez
67.2
39.8
27.4
Alan Trammell
66.9
39.1
27.8
Jim Thome
66.8
36.5
30.3
Jim Edmonds
66.7
42.3
24.4
Pee Wee Reese
66.7
36.7
30.0
Rodriguez Ivan
66.7
33.8
32.9
Eddie Murray
66.7
27.6
39.1
Ron Santo
66.4
37.0
29.4
Gary Carter
66.3
39.6
26.7
Craig Biggio
66.2
31.5
34.7
Manny Ramirez
66.0
36.3
29.7
Rafael Palmeiro
66.0
27.2
38.8
Kenny Lofton
65.3
37.1
28.2
Willie McCovey
65.1
30.8
34.3
Ozzie Smith
64.6
35.6
29.0
Tim Raines
64.6
32.1
32.5
Ernie Banks
64.4
28.7
35.7
Home Run Baker
63.7
41.6
22.1
Al Simmons
63.6
34.4
29.2
Roberto Alomar
63.5
31.8
31.7
Reggie Smith
63.4
38.1
25.3
Gary Sheffield
63.3
30.0
33.3
Jackie Robinson
63.2
43.0
20.2
Mark McGwire
63.1
39.0
24.1
Goose Goslin
63.0
33.3
29.7
Shoeless Joe Jackson
62.9
43.1
19.8
Joe Cronin
62.5
36.4
26.1
Scott Rolen
62.2
40.4
21.8
Ryne Sandberg
62.0
34.8
27.2
Yogi Berra
61.9
38.3
23.6
Dwight Evans
61.8
29.2
32.6
Graig Nettles
61.6
30.0
31.6
Jake Beckley
61.5
29.9
31.6
Dick Allen
61.2
34.8
26.4
Harmon Killebrew
61.1
30.4
30.7
Keith Hernandez
61.0
33.6
27.4
Buddy Bell
60.8
31.1
29.7
Willie Keeler
60.8
30.6
30.2
Sal Bando
60.6
34.8
25.8
Willie Randolph
60.5
33.4
27.1
Bobby Wallace
60.5
31.1
29.4
Jim Wynn
59.8
33.7
26.1
Sammy Sosa
59.7
30.2
29.5
Dave Winfield
59.7
20.1
39.6
Jeff Kent
59.4
31.8
27.6
Mike Piazza
59.1
35.5
23.6
Sherry Magee
59.1
33.1
26.0
Jack Glasscock
58.7
32.4
26.3
Andruw Jones
58.4
35.5
22.9
Ken Boyer
58.4
30.7
27.7
Richie Ashburn
58.0
27.3
30.7
Bid McPhee
57.9
31.9
26.0
Zack Wheat
57.8
28.3
29.5
Will Clark
57.6
30.5
27.1
Todd Helton
57.5
35.1
22.4
Willie Stargell
57.5
26.0
31.5
Darrell Evans
57.3
24.3
33.0
Willie Davis
57.2
26.7
30.5
Billy Williams
57.2
21.9
35.3
Vladimir Guerrero
57.1
33.0
24.1
Bobby Abreu
57.1
32.3
24.8
Bobby Bonds
57.0
32.8
24.2
Andre Dawson
57.0
23.5
33.5
Hank Greenberg
56.8
39.8
17.0
John Olerud
56.8
26.9
29.9
Elmer Flick
56.7
35.0
21.7
Lou Boudreau
56.0
39.6
16.4
Joe Medwick
55.8
29.1
26.7
Billy Herman
55.6
29.6
26.0
Joe Torre
55.6
26.9
28.7
Joe Kelley
55.5
30.6
24.9
Robin Ventura
55.5
28.7
26.8
Bill Terry
55.4
33.9
21.5
Jack Clark
55.0
27.3
27.7
Joe Gordon
54.9
38.5
16.4
Stan Hack
54.8
28.6
26.2
Carlos Beltran
54.7
33.7
21.0
Bill Dickey
54.4
33.2
21.2
Enos Slaughter
54.1
23.4
30.7
Jim O'Rourke
53.9
29.1
24.8
Bob Johnson
53.2
31.8
21.4
Jimmy Collins
53.0
29.0
24.0
Norm Cash
52.9
28.0
24.9
Minnie Minoso
52.8
31.2
21.6
Jason Giambi
52.7
26.2
26.5
Harry Hooper
52.5
20.1
32.4
Bob Elliott
52.3
24.4
27.9
Cesar Cedeno
52.2
27.1
25.1
Jose Cruz
52.2
23.9
28.3
Ron Cey
52.0
26.4
25.6
Buck Ewing
51.8
33.1
18.7
Jimmy Sheckard
51.8
25.0
26.8
Mickey Cochrane
51.2
31.8
19.4
Sam Rice
51.1
19.4
31.7
Tommy Leach
50.9
25.4
25.5
Ichiro Suzuki
50.7
30.6
20.1
Max Carey
50.6
21.4
29.2
Fred McGriff
50.5
19.4
31.1
Tony Perez
50.5
16.3
34.2
George Sisler
50.4
23.6
26.8
Ted Simmons
50.4
21.6
28.8
Gabby Hartnett
50.3
26.8
23.5
Chet Lemon
49.9
25.1
24.8
Luis Aparicio
49.9
21.7
28.2
Hugh Duffy
49.6
28.3
21.3
Kiki Cuyler
49.6
26.1
23.5
Frank Chance
49.5
34.3
15.2
Brian Downing
49.4
20.0
29.4
John McGraw
49.3
33.5
15.8
Vada Pinson
49.3
13.9
35.4
Joe Tinker
49.2
33.3
15.9
Gene Tenace
48.7
30.1
18.6
King Kelly
48.5
30.0
18.5
Johnny Evers
48.4
29.6
18.8
Joe Sewell
48.4
22.4
26.0
Tony Lazzeri
48.3
24.8
23.5
Tony Phillips
48.2
20.6
27.6
Hughie Jennings
48.0
28.8
19.2
Ellis Burks
47.9
22.3
25.6
Fielder Jones
47.8
24.7
23.1
Bobby Doerr
47.7
28.1
19.6
Larry Doby
47.4
30.0
17.4
Fred Lynn
47.3
22.5
24.8
Bernie Williams
47.3
18.7
28.6
Cupid Childs
47.2
27.2
20.0
Larry Doyle
47.2
25.7
21.5
Mark Grace
47.1
20.1
27.0
Toby Harrah
47.1
19.5
27.6
Harry Stovey
46.8
32.9
13.9
Orlando Cepeda
46.8
16.1
30.7
Sam Thompson
46.7
28.0
18.7
Johnny Damon
46.7
16.9
29.8
Mike Cameron
46.6
23.4
23.2
Edd Roush
46.5
24.0
22.5
Brett Butler
46.5
19.0
27.5
Heinie Groh
46.4
26.8
19.6
Dave Bancroft
46.4
24.5
21.9
Rocky Colavito
46.4
24.2
22.2
Luis Gonzalez
46.3
16.7
29.6
Jim Fregosi
46.1
25.1
21.0
George Gore
45.9
29.1
16.8
Mike Tiernan
45.9
26.4
19.5
Ralph Kiner
45.9
24.2
21.7
Bert Campaneris
45.3
19.1
26.2
Mike Griffin
45.2
27.7
17.5
Rusty Staub
45.2
7.6
37.6
George Burns
45.1
22.0
23.1
George Van Haltren
45.1
21.4
23.7
Dixie Walker
45.1
19.6
25.5
Earl Averill
45.0
24.4
20.6
Ed Konetchy
44.9
20.8
24.1
Jimmy Ryan
44.9
20.0
24.9
Kirby Puckett
44.8
21.7
23.1
Lave Cross
44.8
14.8
30.0
Lance Berkman
44.7
26.4
18.3
Earle Combs
44.7
25.5
19.2
Herman Long
44.6
19.5
25.1
Gil Hodges
44.6
16.7
27.9
Roy White
44.5
19.6
24.9
Jorge Posada
44.4
22.3
22.1
Buddy Myer
44.4
19.5
24.9
Nellie Fox
44.4
18.3
26.1
J.D. Drew
44.3
27.5
16.8
Carlos Delgado
44.2
17.4
26.8
Dale Murphy
44.2
15.7
28.5
Heinie Manush
44.1
18.3
25.8
Augie Galan
44.0
22.7
21.3
Matt Williams
43.9
21.8
22.1
Wally Schang
43.8
22.2
21.6
Joe Judge
43.7
14.7
29.0
Bobby Veach
43.6
19.1
24.5
Vern Stephens
43.5
25.6
17.9
Charlie Keller
43.4
32.0
11.4
Thurman Munson
43.4
25.0
18.4
Bill Freehan
43.3
23.2
20.1
Travis Jackson
43.3
23.0
20.3
Omar Vizquel
43.2
7.8
35.4
Deacon White
43.1
22.3
20.8
Dolph Camilli
43.0
22.1
20.9
Larry Gardner
43.0
18.4
24.6
Darryl Strawberry
42.9
21.8
21.1
Art Fletcher
42.8
28.7
14.1
Roy Thomas
42.8
24.3
18.5
Fred Tenney
42.8
17.4
25.4
Brian Giles
42.7
20.3
22.4
Nomar Garciaparra
42.6
23.8
18.8
George Foster
42.5
17.8
24.7
Tony Oliva
42.4
21.0
21.4
Phil Rizzuto
41.8
25.4
16.4
Paul Hines
41.8
21.2
20.6
Jose Canseco
41.8
16.7
25.1
Roger Bresnahan
41.6
26.1
15.5
Andy Van Slyke
41.6
21.2
20.4
Lenny Dykstra
41.5
26.0
15.5
Jim Rice
41.5
13.9
27.6
Devon White
41.3
17.8
23.5
Ben Chapman
41.2
19.6
21.6
Chuck Knoblauch
41.2
18.6
22.6
Del Pratt
40.8
16.0
24.8
Hardy Richardson
40.6
23.0
17.6
Darrell Porter
40.6
20.2
20.4
Miguel Tejada
40.6
14.9
25.7
Ken Singleton
40.6
13.1
27.5
Julio Franco
40.6
11.2
29.4
Jack Fournier
40.5
21.5
19.0
Steve Finley
40.5
10.5
30.0
Roger Peckinpaugh
40.4
15.5
24.9
Amos Otis
40.4
13.5
26.9
Red Schoendienst
40.4
11.4
29.0
Gil McDougald
40.0
25.6
14.4
Wally Berger
40.0
22.2
17.8
Ed McKean
40.0
18.6
21.4
Name WAR WAA RepW WAA%
Ruth, Babe 172.0 140.5 31.5 81.7%
Bonds, Barry 171.8 131.3 40.5 76.4%
Cobb, Ty 159.4 114.8 44.6 72.0%
Mays, Willie 154.7 113.5 41.2 73.4%
Aaron, Hank 141.6 94.2 47.4 66.5%
Wagner, Honus 134.5 100.6 33.9 74.8%
Speaker, Tris 133.0 93.8 39.2 70.5%
Hornsby, Rogers 127.8 99.2 28.6 77.6%
Musial, Stan 127.8 84.7 43.1 66.3%
Collins, Eddie 126.7 88.2 38.5 69.6%
Williams, Ted 125.3 98.5 26.8 78.6%
Mantle, Mickey 120.2 90.0 30.2 74.8%
Gehrig, Lou 118.4 90.9 27.5 76.8%
Henderson, Rickey 113.1 74.6 38.5 65.9%
Ott, Mel 109.3 71.5 37.8 65.4%
Schmidt, Mike 108.3 76.6 31.7 70.8%
Robinson, Frank 107.4 66.6 40.8 62.0%
Lajoie, Nap 104.2 70.3 33.9 67.4%
Morgan, Joe 103.5 68.9 34.6 66.6%
Anson, Cap 99.5 63.4 36.1 63.8%
Rodriguez, Alex 99.0 68.8 30.2 69.5%
Mathews, Eddie 98.3 64.7 33.6 65.8%
Foxx, Jimmie 94.1 66.7 27.4 70.9%
Kaline, Al 91.0 56.6 34.4 62.2%
Davis, George 90.7 59.0 31.7 65.0%
Ripken, Cal 89.9 50.8 39.1 56.5%
Boggs, Wade 89.0 57.5 31.5 64.6%
Yastrzemski, Carl 88.7 46.3 42.4 52.2%
Connor, Roger 87.2 58.5 28.7 67.0%
Brett, George 85.0 49.5 35.5 58.2%
Clemente, Roberto 83.8 50.5 33.3 60.3%
Brouthers, Dan 83.7 61.5 22.2 73.5%
DiMaggio, Joe 83.6 63.8 19.8 76.3%
Gehringer, Charlie 80.9 51.0 29.9 63.1%
Bagwell, Jeff 79.9 52.4 27.5 65.6%
Griffey, Ken 79.3 45.0 34.3 56.8%
Carew, Rod 79.1 47.0 32.1 59.4%
Jones, Chipper 76.9 49.8 27.1 64.8%
Yount, Robin 76.9 40.2 36.7 52.2%
Pujols, Albert 76.6 58.2 18.4 75.9%
Crawford, Sam 76.6 38.9 37.7 50.8%
Dahlen, Bill 75.9 44.9 31.0 59.1%
Thomas, Frank 75.9 44.4 31.5 58.4%
Vaughan, Arky 75.6 50.2 25.4 66.4%
Rose, Pete 75.3 28.2 47.1 37.4%
Frisch, Frankie 74.8 45.5 29.3 60.8%
Molitor, Paul 74.8 39.5 35.3 52.8%
Delahanty, Ed 74.7 50.2 24.5 67.1%
Jackson, Reggie 74.6 36.9 37.7 49.4%
Waner, Paul 73.8 41.3 32.5 56.0%
Clarke, Fred 73.4 44.8 28.6 61.0%
Bench, Johnny 71.3 46.2 25.1 64.8%
Mize, Johnny 70.2 44.1 26.1 62.9%
Whitaker, Lou 69.7 39.7 30.0 56.9%
Hamilton, Billy 69.6 48.7 20.9 69.9%
Heilmann, Harry 69.4 40.3 29.1 58.0%
Appling, Luke 69.3 40.8 28.5 58.9%
Robinson, Brooks 69.1 38.8 30.3 56.2%
Larkin, Barry 68.9 42.4 26.5 61.5%
Jeter, Derek 68.8 38.9 29.9 56.6%
Gwynn, Tony 68.4 37.6 30.8 54.9%
Burkett, Jesse 68.0 40.0 28.0 58.8%
Grich, Bobby 67.6 42.7 24.9 63.2%
Snider, Duke 67.5 38.8 28.7 57.4%
Walker, Larry 67.3 43.0 24.3 63.9%
Fisk, Carlton 67.3 36.2 31.1 53.8%
Martinez, Edgar 67.2 39.8 27.4 59.2%
Trammell, Alan 66.9 39.1 27.8 58.5%
Thome, Jim 66.8 36.5 30.3 54.6%
Edmonds, Jim 66.7 42.3 24.4 63.4%
Reese, Pee Wee 66.7 36.7 30.0 55.0%
Rodriguez, Ivan 66.7 33.8 32.9 50.7%
Murray, Eddie 66.7 27.6 39.1 41.4%
Santo, Ron 66.4 37.0 29.4 55.8%
Carter, Gary 66.3 39.6 26.7 59.8%
Biggio, Craig 66.2 31.5 34.7 47.6%
Ramirez, Manny 66.0 36.3 29.7 55.1%
Palmeiro, Rafael 66.0 27.2 38.8 41.2%
Lofton, Kenny 65.3 37.1 28.2 56.8%
McCovey, Willie 65.1 30.8 34.3 47.4%
Smith, Ozzie 64.6 35.6 29.0 55.1%
Raines, Tim 64.6 32.1 32.5 49.6%
Banks, Ernie 64.4 28.7 35.7 44.5%
Baker, Home Run 63.7 41.6 22.1 65.4%
Simmons, Al 63.6 34.4 29.2 54.1%
Alomar, Roberto 63.5 31.8 31.7 50.0%
Smith, Reggie 63.4 38.1 25.3 60.0%
Sheffield, Gary 63.3 30.0 33.3 47.4%
Robinson, Jackie 63.2 43.0 20.2 68.1%
McGwire, Mark 63.1 39.0 24.1 61.8%
Goslin, Goose 63.0 33.3 29.7 52.8%
Jackson, Shoeless Joe 62.9 43.1 19.8 68.5%
Cronin, Joe 62.5 36.4 26.1 58.3%
Rolen, Scott 62.2 40.4 21.8 64.9%
Sandberg, Ryne 62.0 34.8 27.2 56.2%
Berra, Yogi 61.9 38.3 23.6 61.9%
Evans, Dwight 61.8 29.2 32.6 47.2%
Nettles, Graig 61.6 30.0 31.6 48.8%
Beckley, Jake 61.5 29.9 31.6 48.6%
Allen, Dick 61.2 34.8 26.4 56.9%
Killebrew, Harmon 61.1 30.4 30.7 49.7%
Hernandez, Keith 61.0 33.6 27.4 55.0%
Bell, Buddy 60.8 31.1 29.7 51.2%
Keeler, Willie 60.8 30.6 30.2 50.3%
Bando, Sal 60.6 34.8 25.8 57.4%
Randolph, Willie 60.5 33.4 27.1 55.2%
Wallace, Bobby 60.5 31.1 29.4 51.3%
Wynn, Jim 59.8 33.7 26.1 56.3%
Sosa, Sammy 59.7 30.2 29.5 50.6%
Winfield, Dave 59.7 20.1 39.6 33.6%
Kent, Jeff 59.4 31.8 27.6 53.6%
Piazza, Mike 59.1 35.5 23.6 60.0%
Magee, Sherry 59.1 33.1 26.0 56.1%
Glasscock, Jack 58.7 32.4 26.3 55.2%
Andruw, Jones 58.4 35.5 22.9 60.7%
Boyer, Ken 58.4 30.7 27.7 52.7%
Ashburn, Richie 58.0 27.3 30.7 47.1%
McPhee, Bid 57.9 31.9 26.0 55.1%
Wheat, Zack 57.8 28.3 29.5 49.0%
Clark, Will 57.6 30.5 27.1 52.9%
Helton, Todd 57.5 35.1 22.4 61.1%
Stargell, Willie 57.5 26.0 31.5 45.2%
Evans, Darrell 57.3 24.3 33.0 42.3%
Davis, Willie 57.2 26.7 30.5 46.7%
Williams, Billy 57.2 21.9 35.3 38.3%
Guerrero, Vladimir 57.1 33.0 24.1 57.8%
Abreu, Bobby 57.1 32.3 24.8 56.6%
Bonds, Bobby 57.0 32.8 24.2 57.5%
Dawson, Andre 57.0 23.5 33.5 41.3%
Greenberg, Hank 56.8 39.8 17.0 70.0%
Olerud, John 56.8 26.9 29.9 47.4%
Flick, Elmer 56.7 35.0 21.7 61.7%
Boudreau, Lou 56.0 39.6 16.4 70.8%
Medwick, Joe 55.8 29.1 26.7 52.2%
Herman, Billy 55.6 29.6 26.0 53.3%
Torre, Joe 55.6 26.9 28.7 48.3%
Kelley, Joe 55.5 30.6 24.9 55.2%
Ventura, Robin 55.5 28.7 26.8 51.7%
Terry, Bill 55.4 33.9 21.5 61.2%
Clark, Jack 55.0 27.3 27.7 49.6%
Gordon, Joe 54.9 38.5 16.4 70.1%
Hack, Stan 54.8 28.6 26.2 52.2%
Beltran, Carlos 54.7 33.7 21.0 61.6%
Dickey, Bill 54.4 33.2 21.2 61.0%
Slaughter, Enos 54.1 23.4 30.7 43.3%
O'Rourke, Jim 53.9 29.1 24.8 53.9%
Johnson, Bob 53.2 31.8 21.4 59.8%
Collins, Jimmy 53.0 29.0 24.0 54.7%
Cash, Norm 52.9 28.0 24.9 52.9%
Minoso, Minnie 52.8 31.2 21.6 59.1%
Giambi, Jason 52.7 26.2 26.5 49.8%
Hooper, Harry 52.5 20.1 32.4 38.2%
Elliott, Bob 52.3 24.4 27.9 46.7%
Cedeno, Cesar 52.2 27.1 25.1 51.9%
Cruz, Jose 52.2 23.9 28.3 45.7%
Cey, Ron 52.0 26.4 25.6 50.7%
Ewing, Buck 51.8 33.1 18.7 63.9%
Sheckard, Jimmy 51.8 25.0 26.8 48.3%
Cochrane, Mickey 51.2 31.8 19.4 62.1%
Rice, Sam 51.1 19.4 31.7 37.9%
Leach, Tommy 50.9 25.4 25.5 49.8%
Suzuki, Ichiro 50.7 30.6 20.1 60.4%
Carey, Max 50.6 21.4 29.2 42.3%
McGriff, Fred 50.5 19.4 31.1 38.4%
Perez, Tony 50.5 16.3 34.2 32.2%
Sisler, George 50.4 23.6 26.8 46.7%
Simmons, Ted 50.4 21.6 28.8 42.9%
Hartnett, Gabby 50.3 26.8 23.5 53.3%
Lemon, Chet 49.9 25.1 24.8 50.3%
Aparicio, Luis 49.9 21.7 28.2 43.4%
Duffy, Hugh 49.6 28.3 21.3 57.1%
Cuyler, Kiki 49.6 26.1 23.5 52.6%
Chance, Frank 49.5 34.3 15.2 69.2%
Downing, Brian 49.4 20.0 29.4 40.4%
McGraw, John 49.3 33.5 15.8 68.0%
Pinson, Vada 49.3 13.9 35.4 28.2%
Tinker, Joe 49.2 33.3 15.9 67.6%
Tenace, Gene 48.7 30.1 18.6 61.8%
Kelly, King 48.5 30.0 18.5 61.8%
Evers, Johnny 48.4 29.6 18.8 61.2%
Sewell, Joe 48.4 22.4 26.0 46.2%
Lazzeri, Tony 48.3 24.8 23.5 51.4%
Phillips, Tony 48.2 20.6 27.6 42.7%
Jennings, Hughie 48.0 28.8 19.2 60.1%
Burks, Ellis 47.9 22.3 25.6 46.5%
Jones, Fielder 47.8 24.7 23.1 51.6%
Doerr, Bobby 47.7 28.1 19.6 58.8%
Doby, Larry 47.4 30.0 17.4 63.2%
Lynn, Fred 47.3 22.5 24.8 47.5%
Williams, Bernie 47.3 18.7 28.6 39.6%
Childs, Cupid 47.2 27.2 20.0 57.5%
Doyle, Larry 47.2 25.7 21.5 54.5%
Grace, Mark 47.1 20.1 27.0 42.7%
Harrah, Toby 47.1 19.5 27.6 41.5%
Stovey, Harry 46.8 32.9 13.9 70.3%
Cepeda, Orlando 46.8 16.1 30.7 34.3%
Thompson, Sam 46.7 28.0 18.7 59.9%
Damon, Johnny 46.7 16.9 29.8 36.2%
Cameron, Mike 46.6 23.4 23.2 50.2%
Roush, Edd 46.5 24.0 22.5 51.7%
Butler, Brett 46.5 19.0 27.5 40.9%
Groh, Heinie 46.4 26.8 19.6 57.8%
Bancroft, Dave 46.4 24.5 21.9 52.8%
Colavito, Rocky 46.4 24.2 22.2 52.2%
Gonzalez, Luis 46.3 16.7 29.6 36.0%
Fregosi, Jim 46.1 25.1 21.0 54.5%
Gore, George 45.9 29.1 16.8 63.3%
Tiernan, Mike 45.9 26.4 19.5 57.6%
Kiner, Ralph 45.9 24.2 21.7 52.6%
Campaneris, Bert 45.3 19.1 26.2 42.2%
Griffin, Mike 45.2 27.7 17.5 61.4%
Staub, Rusty 45.2 7.6 37.6 16.8%
Burns, George 45.1 22.0 23.1 48.7%
Van Haltren, George 45.1 21.4 23.7 47.6%
Walker, Dixie 45.1 19.6 25.5 43.5%
Averill, Earl 45.0 24.4 20.6 54.3%
Konetchy, Ed 44.9 20.8 24.1 46.4%
Ryan, Jimmy 44.9 20.0 24.9 44.5%
Puckett, Kirby 44.8 21.7 23.1 48.4%
Cross, Lave 44.8 14.8 30.0 33.0%
Berkman, Lance 44.7 26.4 18.3 59.1%
Combs, Earle 44.7 25.5 19.2 57.1%
Long, Herman 44.6 19.5 25.1 43.8%
Hodges, Gil 44.6 16.7 27.9 37.4%
White, Roy 44.5 19.6 24.9 44.0%
Posada, Jorge 44.4 22.3 22.1 50.3%
Myer, Buddy 44.4 19.5 24.9 43.9%
Fox, Nellie 44.4 18.3 26.1 41.1%
Drew, J.D. 44.3 27.5 16.8 62.2%
Delgado, Carlos 44.2 17.4 26.8 39.4%
Murphy, Dale 44.2 15.7 28.5 35.5%
Manush, Heinie 44.1 18.3 25.8 41.5%
Galan, Augie 44.0 22.7 21.3 51.5%
Williams, Matt 43.9 21.8 22.1 49.7%
Schang, Wally 43.8 22.2 21.6 50.6%
Judge, Joe 43.7 14.7 29.0 33.5%
Veach, Bobby 43.6 19.1 24.5 43.9%
Stephens, Vern 43.5 25.6 17.9 58.9%
Keller, Charlie 43.4 32.0 11.4 73.7%
Munson, Thurman 43.4 25.0 18.4 57.7%
Freehan, Bill 43.3 23.2 20.1 53.5%
Jackson, Travis 43.3 23.0 20.3 53.1%
Vizquel, Omar 43.2 7.8 35.4 18.1%
White, Deacon 43.1 22.3 20.8 51.8%
Camilli, Dolph 43.0 22.1 20.9 51.3%
Gardner, Larry 43.0 18.4 24.6 42.8%
Strawberry, Darryl 42.9 21.8 21.1 50.8%
Fletcher, Art 42.8 28.7 14.1 67.1%
Thomas, Roy 42.8 24.3 18.5 56.7%
Tenney, Fred 42.8 17.4 25.4 40.6%
Giles, Brian 42.7 20.3 22.4 47.6%
Garciaparra, Nomar 42.6 23.8 18.8 56.0%
Foster, George 42.5 17.8 24.7 41.9%
Oliva, Tony 42.4 21.0 21.4 49.6%
Rizzuto, Phil 41.8 25.4 16.4 60.7%
Hines, Paul 41.8 21.2 20.6 50.7%
Canseco, Jose 41.8 16.7 25.1 39.9%
Bresnahan, Roger 41.6 26.1 15.5 62.8%
Van Slyke, Andy 41.6 21.2 20.4 51.0%
Dykstra, Lenny 41.5 26.0 15.5 62.6%
Rice, Jim 41.5 13.9 27.6 33.5%
White, Devon 41.3 17.8 23.5 43.1%
Chapman, Ben 41.2 19.6 21.6 47.6%
Knoblauch, Chuck 41.2 18.6 22.6 45.0%
Pratt, Del 40.8 16.0 24.8 39.3%
Richardson, Hardy 40.6 23.0 17.6 56.6%
Porter, Darrell 40.6 20.2 20.4 49.6%
Tejada, Miguel 40.6 14.9 25.7 36.6%
Singleton, Ken 40.6 13.1 27.5 32.2%
Franco, Julio 40.6 11.2 29.4 27.6%
Fournier, Jack 40.5 21.5 19.0 53.1%
Finley, Steve 40.5 10.5 30.0 26.0%
Peckinpaugh, Roger 40.4 15.5 24.9 38.4%
Otis, Amos 40.4 13.5 26.9 33.4%
Schoendienst, Red 40.4 11.4 29.0 28.3%
McDougald, Gil 40.0 25.6 14.4 64.0%
Berger, Wally 40.0 22.2 17.8 55.5%
McKean, Ed 40.0 18.6 21.4 46.6%