Hall of Fame Timeline
By Adam Darowski for Beyond the Box Score
Click on a filter to see a specific group of players. Hover over a player to see his WAR, WAE, WAM, and wWAR numbers. Be sure to return to the original post at Beyond the Box Score to discuss.
- 1 150+ wWAR
- 2 120–150 wWAR
- 3 90–120 wWAR
- 4 60–90 wWAR
- 5 0–60 wWAR
- Filter:
- Position Players Only (143)
- Pitchers Only (63)
- All Hall of Famers (206)
- 150+ wWAR Only
- Under 60 wWAR Only
- Positions:
- C (13)
- 1B (20)
- 2B (18)
- 3B (10)
- SS (20)
- LF (20)
- CF (17)
- RF (24)
- DH (1)
- Via:
- BBWAA (111)
- Veterans (95)
- Anson Cap Anson 1B (1871–1897)
- WAR
- 99.5
- WAE
- 31.7
- WAM
- 3.8
- wWAR
- 135.0
- O'Rourke Jim O'Rourke LF (1872–1904)
- WAR
- 53.9
- WAE
- 6.2
- WAM
- 0.0
- wWAR
- 60.1
- Galvin Pud Galvin P (1875–1892)
- WAR
- 70.5
- WAE
- 40.4
- WAM
- 18.8
- wWAR
- 129.7
- Ward Monte Ward P (1878–1884)
- WAR
- 25.4
- WAE
- 9
- WAM
- 1.7
- wWAR
- 36.1
- Kelly King Kelly RF (1878–1893)
- WAR
- 48.5
- WAE
- 6.6
- WAM
- 0.0
- wWAR
- 55.1
- Ward Monte Ward SS (1878–1894)
- WAR
- 39.5
- WAE
- 7.0
- WAM
- 1.4
- wWAR
- 47.9
- Brouthers Dan Brouthers 1B (1879–1904)
- WAR
- 83.7
- WAE
- 40.3
- WAM
- 10.4
- wWAR
- 134.4
- Welch Mickey Welch P (1880–1892)
- WAR
- 56.5
- WAE
- 32.9
- WAM
- 12.7
- wWAR
- 102.1
- Keefe Tim Keefe P (1880–1893)
- WAR
- 82.5
- WAE
- 48.9
- WAM
- 23.5
- wWAR
- 154.9
- Connor Roger Connor 1B (1880–1897)
- WAR
- 87.2
- WAE
- 38.6
- WAM
- 9.5
- wWAR
- 135.3
- Ewing Buck Ewing C (1880–1897)
- WAR
- 51.8
- WAE
- 13.8
- WAM
- 0.0
- wWAR
- 65.6
- Radbourn Charles Radbourn P (1881–1891)
- WAR
- 71.6
- WAE
- 44.2
- WAM
- 25.4
- wWAR
- 141.2
- Clarkson John Clarkson P (1882–1894)
- WAR
- 82.1
- WAE
- 53.3
- WAM
- 31.4
- wWAR
- 166.8
- McPhee Bid McPhee 2B (1882–1899)
- WAR
- 57.9
- WAE
- 12.5
- WAM
- 0.0
- wWAR
- 70.4
- McCarthy Tommy McCarthy RF (1884–1896)
- WAR
- 19.0
- WAE
- 3.1
- WAM
- 0.0
- wWAR
- 22.1
- Thompson Sam Thompson RF (1885–1906)
- WAR
- 46.7
- WAE
- 14.1
- WAM
- 0.7
- wWAR
- 61.5
- Hamilton Billy Hamilton CF (1888–1901)
- WAR
- 69.6
- WAE
- 31.8
- WAM
- 5.3
- wWAR
- 106.7
- Delahanty Ed Delahanty LF (1888–1903)
- WAR
- 74.7
- WAE
- 40.9
- WAM
- 12.7
- wWAR
- 128.3
- Duffy Hugh Duffy CF (1888–1906)
- WAR
- 49.6
- WAE
- 16.2
- WAM
- 1.6
- wWAR
- 67.4
- Beckley Jake Beckley 1B (1888–1907)
- WAR
- 61.5
- WAE
- 14.1
- WAM
- 0.0
- wWAR
- 75.6
- Rusie Amos Rusie P (1889–1901)
- WAR
- 60.6
- WAE
- 38.3
- WAM
- 16.8
- wWAR
- 115.7
- Burkett Jesse Burkett LF (1890–1905)
- WAR
- 68.0
- WAE
- 23.3
- WAM
- 3.7
- wWAR
- 95.0
- Nichols Kid Nichols P (1890–1906)
- WAR
- 102.3
- WAE
- 64.1
- WAM
- 28.1
- wWAR
- 194.5
- Davis George Davis SS (1890–1909)
- WAR
- 90.7
- WAE
- 39.6
- WAM
- 5.8
- wWAR
- 136.1
- Young Cy Young P (1890–1911)
- WAR
- 146.0
- WAE
- 87.9
- WAM
- 37.4
- wWAR
- 271.3
- Kelley Joe Kelley LF (1891–1908)
- WAR
- 55.5
- WAE
- 20.0
- WAM
- 3.9
- wWAR
- 79.4
- Griffith Clark Griffith P (1891–1914)
- WAR
- 49.0
- WAE
- 17.9
- WAM
- 3.8
- wWAR
- 70.7
- Jennings Hughie Jennings SS (1891–1918)
- WAR
- 46.4
- WAE
- 26.3
- WAM
- 11.3
- wWAR
- 84.0
- Keeler Willie Keeler RF (1892–1910)
- WAR
- 60.8
- WAE
- 22.0
- WAM
- 2.5
- wWAR
- 85.3
- Clarke Fred Clarke LF (1894–1915)
- WAR
- 73.4
- WAE
- 25.8
- WAM
- 1.2
- wWAR
- 100.4
- Wallace Bobby Wallace SS (1894–1918)
- WAR
- 60.5
- WAE
- 21.4
- WAM
- 2.1
- wWAR
- 84.0
- Collins Jimmy Collins 3B (1895–1908)
- WAR
- 53.0
- WAE
- 20.2
- WAM
- 3.0
- wWAR
- 76.2
- Lajoie Nap Lajoie 2B (1896–1916)
- WAR
- 104.2
- WAE
- 53.4
- WAM
- 17.4
- wWAR
- 175.0
- Waddell Rube Waddell P (1897–1910)
- WAR
- 50.2
- WAE
- 22.3
- WAM
- 8.0
- wWAR
- 80.5
- Bresnahan Roger Bresnahan C (1897–1915)
- WAR
- 41.6
- WAE
- 10.2
- WAM
- 0.0
- wWAR
- 51.8
- Wagner Honus Wagner SS (1897–1917)
- WAR
- 134.5
- WAE
- 68.2
- WAM
- 31.3
- wWAR
- 234.0
- Willis Vic Willis P (1898–1910)
- WAR
- 57.2
- WAE
- 26.7
- WAM
- 6.9
- wWAR
- 90.8
- Flick Elmer Flick RF (1898–1910)
- WAR
- 56.7
- WAE
- 26.3
- WAM
- 3.9
- wWAR
- 86.9
- Chance Frank Chance 1B (1898–1914)
- WAR
- 49.5
- WAE
- 17.6
- WAM
- 2.9
- wWAR
- 70.0
- McGinnity Joe McGinnity P (1899–1908)
- WAR
- 53.7
- WAE
- 27.6
- WAM
- 10.7
- wWAR
- 92.0
- Chesbro Jack Chesbro P (1899–1909)
- WAR
- 33.2
- WAE
- 13.8
- WAM
- 2.8
- wWAR
- 49.8
- Crawford Sam Crawford RF (1899–1917)
- WAR
- 76.6
- WAE
- 28.4
- WAM
- 1.8
- wWAR
- 106.8
- Mathewson Christy Mathewson P (1900–1916)
- WAR
- 87.7
- WAE
- 52.3
- WAM
- 19.3
- wWAR
- 159.3
- Plank Eddie Plank P (1901–1917)
- WAR
- 76.3
- WAE
- 28.2
- WAM
- 1.6
- wWAR
- 106.1
- Joss Addie Joss P (1902–1910)
- WAR
- 40.9
- WAE
- 15.0
- WAM
- 1.5
- wWAR
- 57.4
- Tinker Joe Tinker SS (1902–1916)
- WAR
- 49.2
- WAE
- 11.4
- WAM
- 1.4
- wWAR
- 62.0
- Evers Johnny Evers 2B (1902–1929)
- WAR
- 48.4
- WAE
- 14.0
- WAM
- 0.6
- wWAR
- 63.0
- Brown Mordecai Brown P (1903–1916)
- WAR
- 56.1
- WAE
- 21.5
- WAM
- 5.7
- wWAR
- 83.3
- Bender Chief Bender P (1903–1925)
- WAR
- 38.5
- WAE
- 9.5
- WAM
- 0.0
- wWAR
- 48.0
- Walsh Ed Walsh P (1904–1917)
- WAR
- 54.8
- WAE
- 31.6
- WAM
- 13.3
- wWAR
- 99.7
- Cobb Ty Cobb CF (1905–1928)
- WAR
- 159.4
- WAE
- 93.3
- WAM
- 39.9
- wWAR
- 292.6
- Collins Eddie Collins 2B (1906–1930)
- WAR
- 126.7
- WAE
- 69.4
- WAM
- 27.7
- wWAR
- 223.8
- Johnson Walter Johnson P (1907–1927)
- WAR
- 127.7
- WAE
- 70.8
- WAM
- 31.8
- wWAR
- 230.3
- Speaker Tris Speaker CF (1907–1928)
- WAR
- 133.0
- WAE
- 75.9
- WAM
- 27.0
- wWAR
- 235.9
- Baker Home Run Baker 3B (1908–1922)
- WAR
- 63.7
- WAE
- 30.3
- WAM
- 10.3
- wWAR
- 104.3
- Marquard Rube Marquard P (1908–1925)
- WAR
- 28.5
- WAE
- 9.2
- WAM
- 0.0
- wWAR
- 37.7
- Hooper Harry Hooper RF (1909–1925)
- WAR
- 52.5
- WAE
- 10.6
- WAM
- 0.3
- wWAR
- 63.4
- Wheat Zack Wheat LF (1909–1927)
- WAR
- 57.8
- WAE
- 14.1
- WAM
- 0.9
- wWAR
- 72.8
- Carey Max Carey CF (1910–1929)
- WAR
- 50.6
- WAE
- 11.3
- WAM
- 0.0
- wWAR
- 61.9
- Alexander Pete Alexander P (1911–1930)
- WAR
- 104.9
- WAE
- 52.9
- WAM
- 17.5
- wWAR
- 175.3
- Coveleski Stan Coveleski P (1912–1928)
- WAR
- 54.0
- WAE
- 25.1
- WAM
- 4.2
- wWAR
- 83.3
- Schalk Ray Schalk C (1912–1929)
- WAR
- 22.6
- WAE
- 0.4
- WAM
- 0.0
- wWAR
- 23.0
- Rixey Eppa Rixey P (1912–1933)
- WAR
- 51.2
- WAE
- 12.6
- WAM
- 0.0
- wWAR
- 63.8
- Pennock Herb Pennock P (1912–1934)
- WAR
- 36.9
- WAE
- 11.2
- WAM
- 1.0
- wWAR
- 49.1
- Maranville Rabbit Maranville SS (1912–1935)
- WAR
- 38.2
- WAE
- 6.1
- WAM
- 0.0
- wWAR
- 44.3
- Roush Edd Roush CF (1913–1931)
- WAR
- 46.5
- WAE
- 12.5
- WAM
- 0.5
- wWAR
- 59.5
- Heilmann Harry Heilmann RF (1914–1932)
- WAR
- 69.4
- WAE
- 28.2
- WAM
- 6.2
- wWAR
- 103.8
- Faber Red Faber P (1914–1933)
- WAR
- 55.2
- WAE
- 14.7
- WAM
- 5.8
- wWAR
- 75.7
- Ruth Babe Ruth RF (1914–1935)
- WAR
- 172.0
- WAE
- 100.6
- WAM
- 59.6
- wWAR
- 332.2
- Sisler George Sisler 1B (1915–1930)
- WAR
- 50.4
- WAE
- 24.6
- WAM
- 6.0
- wWAR
- 81.0
- Bancroft Dave Bancroft SS (1915–1930)
- WAR
- 46.4
- WAE
- 16.2
- WAM
- 2.6
- wWAR
- 65.2
- Kelly George Kelly 1B (1915–1932)
- WAR
- 24.3
- WAE
- 3.8
- WAM
- 0.0
- wWAR
- 28.1
- Rice Sam Rice RF (1915–1934)
- WAR
- 51.1
- WAE
- 10.0
- WAM
- 0.0
- wWAR
- 61.1
- Vance Dazzy Vance P (1915–1935)
- WAR
- 56.4
- WAE
- 25.7
- WAM
- 7.7
- wWAR
- 89.8
- Hornsby Rogers Hornsby 2B (1915–1937)
- WAR
- 127.8
- WAE
- 81.4
- WAM
- 41.3
- wWAR
- 250.5
- Grimes Burleigh Grimes P (1916–1934)
- WAR
- 37.2
- WAE
- 10.6
- WAM
- 0.1
- wWAR
- 47.9
- Youngs Ross Youngs RF (1917–1926)
- WAR
- 36.2
- WAE
- 13.4
- WAM
- 1.6
- wWAR
- 51.2
- Haines Jesse Haines P (1918–1937)
- WAR
- 33.8
- WAE
- 4.3
- WAM
- 0.0
- wWAR
- 38.1
- Hoyt Waite Hoyt P (1918–1938)
- WAR
- 47.0
- WAE
- 9.2
- WAM
- 0.0
- wWAR
- 56.2
- Frisch Frankie Frisch 2B (1919–1937)
- WAR
- 74.8
- WAE
- 29.5
- WAM
- 8.7
- wWAR
- 113.0
- Sewell Joe Sewell SS (1920–1933)
- WAR
- 48.4
- WAE
- 13.3
- WAM
- 1.4
- wWAR
- 63.1
- Traynor Pie Traynor 3B (1920–1937)
- WAR
- 37.1
- WAE
- 6.4
- WAM
- 0.0
- wWAR
- 43.5
- Goslin Goose Goslin LF (1921–1938)
- WAR
- 63.0
- WAE
- 21.5
- WAM
- 2.6
- wWAR
- 87.1
- Cuyler Kiki Cuyler RF (1921–1938)
- WAR
- 49.6
- WAE
- 17.3
- WAM
- 1.5
- wWAR
- 68.4
- Jackson Travis Jackson SS (1922–1936)
- WAR
- 43.3
- WAE
- 15.0
- WAM
- 0.5
- wWAR
- 58.8
- Bottomley Jim Bottomley 1B (1922–1937)
- WAR
- 32.4
- WAE
- 7.1
- WAM
- 0.0
- wWAR
- 39.5
- Hartnett Gabby Hartnett C (1922–1941)
- WAR
- 50.3
- WAE
- 8.3
- WAM
- 0.0
- wWAR
- 58.6
- Wilson Hack Wilson CF (1923–1934)
- WAR
- 39.1
- WAE
- 15.5
- WAM
- 2.4
- wWAR
- 57.0
- Terry Bill Terry 1B (1923–1936)
- WAR
- 55.4
- WAE
- 23.6
- WAM
- 4.5
- wWAR
- 83.5
- Gehrig Lou Gehrig 1B (1923–1939)
- WAR
- 118.4
- WAE
- 76.4
- WAM
- 39.0
- wWAR
- 233.8
- Manush Heinie Manush LF (1923–1939)
- WAR
- 44.1
- WAE
- 13.0
- WAM
- 1.5
- wWAR
- 58.6
- Lyons Ted Lyons P (1923–1946)
- WAR
- 58.8
- WAE
- 16.4
- WAM
- 0.0
- wWAR
- 75.2
- Combs Earle Combs CF (1924–1935)
- WAR
- 44.7
- WAE
- 12.5
- WAM
- 1.0
- wWAR
- 58.2
- Lindstrom Freddie Lindstrom 3B (1924–1936)
- WAR
- 29.2
- WAE
- 7.8
- WAM
- 1.0
- wWAR
- 38.0
- Hafey Chick Hafey LF (1924–1937)
- WAR
- 29.5
- WAE
- 7.3
- WAM
- 0.0
- wWAR
- 36.8
- Gehringer Charlie Gehringer 2B (1924–1942)
- WAR
- 80.9
- WAE
- 40.1
- WAM
- 10.5
- wWAR
- 131.5
- Simmons Al Simmons LF (1924–1944)
- WAR
- 63.6
- WAE
- 25.6
- WAM
- 4.9
- wWAR
- 94.1
- Ruffing Red Ruffing P (1924–1947)
- WAR
- 53.6
- WAE
- 14.2
- WAM
- 0.3
- wWAR
- 68.1
- Cochrane Mickey Cochrane C (1925–1937)
- WAR
- 51.2
- WAE
- 17.9
- WAM
- 0.3
- wWAR
- 69.4
- Grove Lefty Grove P (1925–1941)
- WAR
- 98.3
- WAE
- 55.1
- WAM
- 18.2
- wWAR
- 171.6
- Foxx Jimmie Foxx 1B (1925–1945)
- WAR
- 94.1
- WAE
- 50.7
- WAM
- 18.0
- wWAR
- 162.8
- Lazzeri Tony Lazzeri 2B (1926–1939)
- WAR
- 48.3
- WAE
- 13.5
- WAM
- 1.8
- wWAR
- 63.6
- Waner Paul Waner RF (1926–1945)
- WAR
- 73.8
- WAE
- 30.2
- WAM
- 4.3
- wWAR
- 108.3
- Cronin Joe Cronin SS (1926–1945)
- WAR
- 62.5
- WAE
- 24.2
- WAM
- 4.9
- wWAR
- 91.6
- Ott Mel Ott RF (1926–1947)
- WAR
- 109.3
- WAE
- 56.5
- WAM
- 13.6
- wWAR
- 179.4
- Waner Lloyd Waner CF (1927–1945)
- WAR
- 24.3
- WAE
- 2.1
- WAM
- 0.0
- wWAR
- 26.4
- Hubbell Carl Hubbell P (1928–1943)
- WAR
- 64.4
- WAE
- 26.0
- WAM
- 7.4
- wWAR
- 97.8
- Klein Chuck Klein RF (1928–1944)
- WAR
- 39.2
- WAE
- 13.4
- WAM
- 1.8
- wWAR
- 54.4
- Dickey Bill Dickey C (1928–1946)
- WAR
- 54.4
- WAE
- 14.2
- WAM
- 0.3
- wWAR
- 68.9
- Averill Earl Averill CF (1929–1941)
- WAR
- 45.0
- WAE
- 15.2
- WAM
- 0.7
- wWAR
- 60.9
- Ferrell Rick Ferrell C (1929–1947)
- WAR
- 22.9
- WAE
- 0.0
- WAM
- 0.0
- wWAR
- 22.9
- Gomez Lefty Gomez P (1930–1943)
- WAR
- 43.0
- WAE
- 17.7
- WAM
- 5.0
- wWAR
- 65.7
- Greenberg Hank Greenberg 1B (1930–1947)
- WAR
- 56.8
- WAE
- 27.2
- WAM
- 6.9
- wWAR
- 90.9
- Dean Dizzy Dean P (1930–1947)
- WAR
- 39.6
- WAE
- 17.7
- WAM
- 3.5
- wWAR
- 60.8
- Appling Luke Appling SS (1930–1950)
- WAR
- 69.3
- WAE
- 26.9
- WAM
- 3.2
- wWAR
- 99.4
- Herman Billy Herman 2B (1931–1947)
- WAR
- 55.6
- WAE
- 16.1
- WAM
- 1.6
- wWAR
- 73.3
- Lombardi Ernie Lombardi C (1931–1947)
- WAR
- 39.0
- WAE
- 4.0
- WAM
- 0.0
- wWAR
- 43.0
- Vaughan Arky Vaughan SS (1932–1948)
- WAR
- 75.6
- WAE
- 37.5
- WAM
- 10.3
- wWAR
- 123.4
- Medwick Joe Medwick LF (1932–1948)
- WAR
- 55.8
- WAE
- 20.8
- WAM
- 5.0
- wWAR
- 81.6
- DiMaggio Joe DiMaggio CF (1936–1951)
- WAR
- 83.6
- WAE
- 42.9
- WAM
- 12.8
- wWAR
- 139.3
- Mize Johnny Mize 1B (1936–1953)
- WAR
- 70.2
- WAE
- 34.4
- WAM
- 6.3
- wWAR
- 110.9
- Feller Bob Feller P (1936–1956)
- WAR
- 66.0
- WAE
- 31.3
- WAM
- 11.6
- wWAR
- 108.9
- Doerr Bobby Doerr 2B (1937–1951)
- WAR
- 47.7
- WAE
- 14.4
- WAM
- 0.4
- wWAR
- 62.5
- Gordon Joe Gordon 2B (1938–1950)
- WAR
- 54.9
- WAE
- 24.9
- WAM
- 4.2
- wWAR
- 84.0
- Boudreau Lou Boudreau SS (1938–1952)
- WAR
- 56.0
- WAE
- 23.3
- WAM
- 7.3
- wWAR
- 86.6
- Slaughter Enos Slaughter RF (1938–1959)
- WAR
- 54.1
- WAE
- 14.8
- WAM
- 1.1
- wWAR
- 70.0
- Newhouser Hal Newhouser P (1939–1955)
- WAR
- 56.3
- WAE
- 25.3
- WAM
- 7.3
- wWAR
- 88.9
- Williams Ted Williams LF (1939–1960)
- WAR
- 125.3
- WAE
- 74.7
- WAM
- 33.9
- wWAR
- 233.9
- Wynn Early Wynn P (1939–1963)
- WAR
- 52.0
- WAE
- 16.0
- WAM
- 2.2
- wWAR
- 70.2
- Reese Pee Wee Reese SS (1940–1958)
- WAR
- 66.7
- WAE
- 26.0
- WAM
- 1.5
- wWAR
- 94.2
- Rizzuto Phil Rizzuto SS (1941–1956)
- WAR
- 41.8
- WAE
- 14.2
- WAM
- 1.1
- wWAR
- 57.1
- Musial Stan Musial LF (1941–1963)
- WAR
- 127.8
- WAE
- 58.9
- WAM
- 20.8
- wWAR
- 207.5
- Spahn Warren Spahn P (1942–1965)
- WAR
- 93.4
- WAE
- 42.6
- WAM
- 7.5
- wWAR
- 143.5
- Kell George Kell 3B (1943–1957)
- WAR
- 33.6
- WAE
- 6.3
- WAM
- 0.0
- wWAR
- 39.9
- Schoendienst Red Schoendienst 2B (1945–1963)
- WAR
- 40.4
- WAE
- 9.6
- WAM
- 0.5
- wWAR
- 50.5
- Kiner Ralph Kiner LF (1946–1955)
- WAR
- 45.9
- WAE
- 20.5
- WAM
- 5.7
- wWAR
- 72.1
- Lemon Bob Lemon P (1946–1958)
- WAR
- 42.4
- WAE
- 13.6
- WAM
- 0.0
- wWAR
- 56.0
- Berra Yogi Berra C (1946–1965)
- WAR
- 61.9
- WAE
- 19.2
- WAM
- 1.5
- wWAR
- 82.6
- Robinson Jackie Robinson 2B (1947–1956)
- WAR
- 63.2
- WAE
- 33.4
- WAM
- 13.6
- wWAR
- 110.2
- Doby Larry Doby CF (1947–1959)
- WAR
- 47.4
- WAE
- 18.0
- WAM
- 1.6
- wWAR
- 67.0
- Snider Duke Snider CF (1947–1964)
- WAR
- 67.5
- WAE
- 31.0
- WAM
- 9.8
- wWAR
- 108.3
- Fox Nellie Fox 2B (1947–1965)
- WAR
- 44.4
- WAE
- 14.8
- WAM
- 1.5
- wWAR
- 60.7
- Campanella Roy Campanella C (1948–1957)
- WAR
- 36.2
- WAE
- 14.5
- WAM
- 2.2
- wWAR
- 52.9
- Ashburn Richie Ashburn CF (1948–1962)
- WAR
- 58.0
- WAE
- 23.4
- WAM
- 0.8
- wWAR
- 82.2
- Roberts Robin Roberts P (1948–1966)
- WAR
- 80.9
- WAE
- 32.8
- WAM
- 10.5
- wWAR
- 124.2
- Ford Whitey Ford P (1950–1967)
- WAR
- 55.3
- WAE
- 14.3
- WAM
- 0.3
- wWAR
- 69.9
- Mantle Mickey Mantle CF (1951–1968)
- WAR
- 120.2
- WAE
- 68.6
- WAM
- 30.9
- wWAR
- 219.7
- Mays Willie Mays CF (1951–1973)
- WAR
- 154.7
- WAE
- 94.8
- WAM
- 45.6
- wWAR
- 295.1
- Mathews Eddie Mathews 3B (1952–1968)
- WAR
- 98.3
- WAE
- 51.6
- WAM
- 15.8
- wWAR
- 165.7
- Wilhelm Hoyt Wilhelm P (1952–1972)
- WAR
- 41.3
- WAE
- 5.1
- WAM
- 1.4
- wWAR
- 47.8
- Banks Ernie Banks 1B (1953–1971)
- WAR
- 64.4
- WAE
- 31.7
- WAM
- 12.7
- wWAR
- 108.8
- Kaline Al Kaline RF (1953–1974)
- WAR
- 91.0
- WAE
- 37.2
- WAM
- 6.7
- wWAR
- 134.9
- Killebrew Harmon Killebrew 1B (1954–1975)
- WAR
- 61.1
- WAE
- 21.6
- WAM
- 1.2
- wWAR
- 83.9
- Aaron Hank Aaron RF (1954–1976)
- WAR
- 141.6
- WAE
- 80.7
- WAM
- 28.8
- wWAR
- 251.1
- Koufax Sandy Koufax P (1955–1966)
- WAR
- 54.5
- WAE
- 29.6
- WAM
- 13.6
- wWAR
- 97.7
- Bunning Jim Bunning P (1955–1971)
- WAR
- 60.1
- WAE
- 28.5
- WAM
- 7.7
- wWAR
- 96.3
- Clemente Roberto Clemente RF (1955–1972)
- WAR
- 83.8
- WAE
- 37.3
- WAM
- 8.0
- wWAR
- 129.1
- Robinson Brooks Robinson 3B (1955–1977)
- WAR
- 69.1
- WAE
- 25.1
- WAM
- 4.4
- wWAR
- 98.6
- Drysdale Don Drysdale P (1956–1969)
- WAR
- 65.7
- WAE
- 28.4
- WAM
- 3.9
- wWAR
- 98.0
- Mazeroski Bill Mazeroski 2B (1956–1972)
- WAR
- 26.9
- WAE
- 2.0
- WAM
- 0.0
- wWAR
- 28.9
- Aparicio Luis Aparicio SS (1956–1973)
- WAR
- 49.9
- WAE
- 9.6
- WAM
- 0.0
- wWAR
- 59.5
- Robinson Frank Robinson RF (1956–1976)
- WAR
- 107.4
- WAE
- 48.6
- WAM
- 9.6
- wWAR
- 165.6
- Cepeda Orlando Cepeda 1B (1958–1974)
- WAR
- 46.8
- WAE
- 13.1
- WAM
- 1.2
- wWAR
- 61.1
- Gibson Bob Gibson P (1959–1975)
- WAR
- 85.6
- WAE
- 44.1
- WAM
- 16.3
- wWAR
- 146.0
- Williams Billy Williams LF (1959–1976)
- WAR
- 57.2
- WAE
- 18.0
- WAM
- 1.8
- wWAR
- 77.0
- McCovey Willie McCovey 1B (1959–1980)
- WAR
- 65.1
- WAE
- 25.1
- WAM
- 5.1
- wWAR
- 95.3
- Marichal Juan Marichal P (1960–1975)
- WAR
- 64.0
- WAE
- 30.4
- WAM
- 11.5
- wWAR
- 105.9
- Brock Lou Brock LF (1961–1979)
- WAR
- 39.1
- WAE
- 8.7
- WAM
- 0.0
- wWAR
- 47.8
- Yastrzemski Carl Yastrzemski LF (1961–1983)
- WAR
- 88.7
- WAE
- 36.4
- WAM
- 13.6
- wWAR
- 138.7
- Stargell Willie Stargell LF (1962–1982)
- WAR
- 57.5
- WAE
- 18.7
- WAM
- 4.2
- wWAR
- 80.4
- Perry Gaylord Perry P (1962–1983)
- WAR
- 96.3
- WAE
- 46.0
- WAM
- 12.5
- wWAR
- 154.8
- Morgan Joe Morgan 2B (1963–1984)
- WAR
- 103.5
- WAE
- 51.0
- WAM
- 21.2
- wWAR
- 175.7
- Perez Tony Perez 1B (1964–1986)
- WAR
- 50.5
- WAE
- 15.6
- WAM
- 0.7
- wWAR
- 66.8
- Niekro Phil Niekro P (1964–1987)
- WAR
- 96.8
- WAE
- 43.8
- WAM
- 9.8
- wWAR
- 150.4
- Hunter Catfish Hunter P (1965–1979)
- WAR
- 32.5
- WAE
- 11.7
- WAM
- 2.0
- wWAR
- 46.2
- Jenkins Fergie Jenkins P (1965–1983)
- WAR
- 81.3
- WAE
- 33.9
- WAM
- 8.6
- wWAR
- 123.8
- Palmer Jim Palmer P (1965–1984)
- WAR
- 63.5
- WAE
- 27.4
- WAM
- 4.5
- wWAR
- 95.4
- Carlton Steve Carlton P (1965–1988)
- WAR
- 84.4
- WAE
- 35.3
- WAM
- 10.8
- wWAR
- 130.5
- Sutton Don Sutton P (1966–1988)
- WAR
- 70.8
- WAE
- 16.7
- WAM
- 0.4
- wWAR
- 87.9
- Ryan Nolan Ryan P (1966–1993)
- WAR
- 84.8
- WAE
- 25.8
- WAM
- 4.7
- wWAR
- 115.3
- Bench Johnny Bench C (1967–1983)
- WAR
- 71.3
- WAE
- 31.3
- WAM
- 5.8
- wWAR
- 108.4
- Carew Rod Carew 1B (1967–1985)
- WAR
- 79.1
- WAE
- 31.4
- WAM
- 9.7
- wWAR
- 120.2
- Seaver Tom Seaver P (1967–1986)
- WAR
- 105.3
- WAE
- 51.6
- WAM
- 13.5
- wWAR
- 170.4
- Jackson Reggie Jackson RF (1967–1987)
- WAR
- 74.6
- WAE
- 33.3
- WAM
- 7.5
- wWAR
- 115.4
- Fingers Rollie Fingers P (1968–1985)
- WAR
- 24.4
- WAE
- 1.8
- WAM
- 0.0
- wWAR
- 26.2
- Fisk Carlton Fisk C (1969–1993)
- WAR
- 67.3
- WAE
- 17.8
- WAM
- 2.0
- wWAR
- 87.1
- Blyleven Bert Blyleven P (1970–1992)
- WAR
- 90.1
- WAE
- 36.1
- WAM
- 4.9
- wWAR
- 131.1
- Schmidt Mike Schmidt 3B (1972–1989)
- WAR
- 108.3
- WAE
- 63.2
- WAM
- 22.3
- wWAR
- 193.8
- Gossage Rich Gossage P (1972–1994)
- WAR
- 40.0
- WAE
- 9.2
- WAM
- 1.0
- wWAR
- 50.2
- Brett George Brett 3B (1973–1993)
- WAR
- 85.0
- WAE
- 39.1
- WAM
- 11.9
- wWAR
- 136.0
- Winfield Dave Winfield RF (1973–1995)
- WAR
- 59.7
- WAE
- 17.3
- WAM
- 2.4
- wWAR
- 79.4
- Rice Jim Rice LF (1974–1989)
- WAR
- 41.5
- WAE
- 13.0
- WAM
- 1.0
- wWAR
- 55.5
- Carter Gary Carter C (1974–1992)
- WAR
- 66.3
- WAE
- 28.2
- WAM
- 4.1
- wWAR
- 98.6
- Yount Robin Yount SS (1974–1993)
- WAR
- 76.9
- WAE
- 29.3
- WAM
- 7.9
- wWAR
- 114.1
- Eckersley Dennis Eckersley P (1975–1998)
- WAR
- 58.7
- WAE
- 14.1
- WAM
- 1.2
- wWAR
- 74.0
- Sutter Bruce Sutter P (1976–1988)
- WAR
- 25.0
- WAE
- 7.1
- WAM
- 0.3
- wWAR
- 32.4
- Dawson Andre Dawson RF (1976–1996)
- WAR
- 57.0
- WAE
- 18.3
- WAM
- 3.4
- wWAR
- 78.7
- Murray Eddie Murray 1B (1977–1997)
- WAR
- 66.7
- WAE
- 22.2
- WAM
- 1.7
- wWAR
- 90.6
- Smith Ozzie Smith SS (1978–1996)
- WAR
- 64.6
- WAE
- 20.4
- WAM
- 1.4
- wWAR
- 86.4
- Molitor Paul Molitor 3B (1978–1998)
- WAR
- 74.8
- WAE
- 22.8
- WAM
- 1.1
- wWAR
- 98.7
- Henderson Rickey Henderson LF (1979–2003)
- WAR
- 113.1
- WAE
- 54.6
- WAM
- 17.7
- wWAR
- 185.4
- Sandberg Ryne Sandberg 2B (1981–1997)
- WAR
- 62.0
- WAE
- 24.2
- WAM
- 5.2
- wWAR
- 91.4
- Ripken Cal Ripken SS (1981–2001)
- WAR
- 89.9
- WAE
- 39.4
- WAM
- 12.2
- wWAR
- 141.5
- Boggs Wade Boggs 3B (1982–1999)
- WAR
- 89.0
- WAE
- 41.8
- WAM
- 14.7
- wWAR
- 145.5
- Gwynn Tony Gwynn RF (1982–2001)
- WAR
- 68.4
- WAE
- 20.1
- WAM
- 3.1
- wWAR
- 91.6
- Puckett Kirby Puckett CF (1984–1995)
- WAR
- 44.8
- WAE
- 13.8
- WAM
- 1.9
- wWAR
- 60.5
- Alomar Roberto Alomar 2B (1988–2004)
- WAR
- 63.5
- WAE
- 23.9
- WAM
- 4.2
- wWAR
- 91.6
Wins Above Replacement (WAR) data from Baseball-Reference.com. Wins Above Excellence (WAE) is the total of all single season WAR above 3.0. Wins Above MVP (WAM) is the total of all single season WAR above 6.0. Wins Above Excellence aims to measure only "excellent" seasons while Wins Above MVP aims to capture dominant MVP-worthy performances. Weighted WAR (wWAR) is the combination of WAR, WAE, and WAM.